MM2 Item Values Explained - Rarity, Demand and Stability

Updated 2026-10-26 · 4 min read

Every MM2 trader has heard the question "Is this a win or a loss?" The answer always comes down to item values. This guide explains where values come from, what each rarity tier means and why two items from the same tier can be worth very different amounts.

What "value" means in MM2

MM2 has no official price list. The game shows each weapon's rarity tier, but not what it's worth in a trade. Values are community estimates from fan-run value lists that watch lots of trades.

A few things to keep in mind:

Values aren't Robux or real money. They're points used to compare items with each other.
Different lists use different units. One popular list measures everything in Seers (a craftable Godly knife), while another uses its own value units.
Lists don't always agree, and they change after updates, events and big trading trends.

So treat any value as a helpful guide, not a fixed price.

The rarity tiers

Every weapon in MM2 belongs to a tier, shown by the color of its label. Here they are from the hardest to get down to the easiest.

Unique (orange)

This is the top tier. Most Unique weapons were given out as rewards, for example to players who placed on an event leaderboard, and almost all of them can't be traded. The best-known exception is Corrupt, a knife first handed out to players hit by an early data-loss glitch.

Ancient (purple)

Ancients sit one step above Godlies. They usually come from holiday events, as high-tier event rewards, or from special gamepasses, and they have never been available from boxes. Many look like scythes or axes rather than regular knives. After an event ends, its Ancient can usually only be picked up through trading.

Godly (pink)

Godlies are the heart of MM2 trading. They come from boxes (at a very small chance), crafting, gamepasses, events and codes. Because there are so many different Godlies, their values range from fairly modest to very high.

Chroma

Chromas are color-shifting versions of certain Godly weapons. In the game they belong to the Godly tier, but traders usually treat them as their own group because they're much harder to get than the regular version. Some can be unboxed at an extremely low chance, one can be crafted, and event Chromas become trade-only once their event is over.

Vintage (yellow)

Vintage weapons come from the original Murder Mystery, the game that came before MM2. Today the only way to get one is by trading. No new copies are being made, so they mostly appeal to collectors.

Legendary, Rare, Uncommon and Common

These lower tiers (red, green, blue and gray) are easy to get from boxes, crafting and events. They're fun for your loadout but rarely carry much trade value.

Why tier isn't everything

A higher tier doesn't automatically mean a higher value. A Godly from a long-gone holiday event can be worth more than an Ancient that's still easy to find, and two Godlies can be worlds apart. Value lists usually weigh four things:

Rarity: how many copies exist and whether more can still be made.
Demand: how many players actually want it. A rare item that nobody wants is hard to trade.
Stability: whether the value is holding steady, rising or dropping.
Base value: what the item normally trades for in a fair deal.

Demand in practice

High-demand items are easy to trade and often get "overpays," meaning people offer a little extra. Low-demand items can be hard to trade away even at their listed value.

Stability tags

Many value lists add a short tag next to each item. Common ones include:

Stable: trades at about its listed value.
Rising or Hyped: demand is growing and offers are above normal.
Fluctuating: offers swing up and down, so it's hard to predict.
Decreasing or Underpaid: the value is slipping and offers come in below the list.

What can crash a value

The biggest threat to values in MM2's history has been duping, which means glitches that let people copy items. When an item gets duplicated in large numbers, the supply jumps and the value can fall hard. Several famous items, including Corrupt and many Chromas, lost a big part of their value this way. Some value lists flag items hit by recent duping, so look for warnings before trading for something expensive.

New events can shake things up too, because fresh items (sometimes including new Chromas) change what players want.

Using values the smart way

Check a recent value list before every big trade, and compare more than one list when you can.
Look at demand and stability, not just the number.
Be careful with anyone who says your item is "about to crash" so they can get it from you cheap.
If you'd rather skip the trading grind for one specific item, GetPets sells MM2 weapons and delivers them through the regular in-game trade window, so you never have to share your password.

Values move all the time, so check before you trade and never rush.